Centennial Conference Awards
Centennial Conference Player of the Year
2011: Jeff Ocampo
2015: Ryan Ridinger (Defensive)
2016: Brian Neff (Defensive)
*The CC separated Player of the Year into offensive and defensive categories in 2014
Centennial Conference Rookie of the Year
2016: Peter DeSimone
Centennial Conference Coach of the Year
2015: Jamie Steele
2019: Gary Mercadante
All-Centennial Conference
| Year | First Team | Second Team | Honorable Mention |
| 2022 | Tyler Neal, Chase Rondeau | Tommy Reinhart, Joshua Toth | Joshua Grahame |
| 2021 | Hakan Atillasoy, Tommy Reinhart | Ben Goetz, Tyler Neal, Joshua Toth | |
| 2019 | Bobby McClure, Evan Scott | Hakan Atillasoy, Peter DeSimone, Alex Middleman, Nolan Sachs | |
| 2018 | Evan Scott | ||
| 2017 | Gerard Brown, Matt Cioeta | Peter DeSimone | |
| 2016 | Gerard Brown, Matt Cioeta, James Fairchild, Zach Jones, Brian Neff | Peter DeSimone, Steve Mussoline, Patrick O'Donoghue | |
| 2015 | Brian Neff, Ryan Ridinger, Mark Stratton, Jake Weber | Mike Durst, James Fairchild, Zach Jones, Patrick O'Donoghue | |
| 2014 | Brian Neff, Ryan Ridinger | Steve Smyrl, Jake Weber | Nile Thompson |
| 2013 | Brian Neff, Ryan Ridinger | ||
| 2012 | Mark Stratton | ||
| 2011 | Logan Duffie, Jeff Ocampo | Tom Adelsberger, Josh Baker | |
| 2010 | Jeff Ocampo | Jake West | Eric Farris |
| 2009 | Eric Farris | Tony Aquilino | |
| 2008 | Dane Mangin | Eric Hoffman | Tony Aquilino, Derrin Mangin |
| 2007 | Dane Mangin | ||
| 2006 | Dane Mangin |