USILA All-Americans
(2020 - Maverik Media All-Americans)
| Year | Name | Team | Position |
| 2022 | Tyler Neal | Honorable Mention | Attack |
| 2021 | Hakan Atillasoy | Honorable Mention | Attack |
| 2020 | Hakan Atillasoy | Fourth | Attack |
| Parker Wolf | Fourth | Defense | |
| Bobby McClure | Honorable Mention | Attack | |
| 2019 | Peter DeSimone | Honorable Mention | Attack |
| Bobby McClure | Honorable Mention | Attack | |
| 2017 | Gerard Brown | Honorable Mention | Midfielder |
| 2016 | Brian Neff | Second | Goalkeeper |
| Gerard Brown | Honorable Mention | Midfield | |
| Zach Jones | Honorable Mention | Defense | |
| 2015 | Ryan Ridinger | Second | Defense |
| Brian Neff | Third | Goalkeeper | |
| Jake Weber | Third | Midfield | |
| Mark Stratton | Honorable Mention | Attack | |
| 2014 | Brian Neff | Honorable Mention | Goalkeeper |
| Ryan Ridinger | Honorable Mention | Defense | |
| 2011 | Jeff Ocampo | Honorable Mention | Attack |
| 2010 | Jeff Ocampo | Honorable Mention | Midfield |
| 2008 | Dane Mangin | Honorable Mention | Midfield |
| 2007 | Dane Mangin | Honorable Mention | Midfield |